Add automatic tiebreaker for search requests that use a PIT (#68833)

This PR adds the special `_shard_doc` sort tiebreaker automatically to any
search requests that use a PIT. Adding the tiebreaker ensures that any
sorted query can be paginated consistently within a PIT.

Closes #56828

docs/reference/search/search-your-data/paginate-search-results.asciidoc

@@ -71,9 +71,15 @@ To get the first page of results, submit a search request with a `sort`
 argument. If using a PIT, specify the PIT ID in the `pit.id` parameter and omit
 the target data stream or index from the request path.
 
-IMPORTANT: We recommend you include a tiebreaker field in your `sort`. This
-tiebreaker field should contain a unique value for each document. If you don't
-include a tiebreaker field, your paged results could miss or duplicate hits.
+IMPORTANT: All PIT search requests add an implicit sort tiebreaker field called `_shard_doc`,
+which can also be provided explicitly.
+If you cannot use a PIT, we recommend that you include a tiebreaker field
+in your `sort`. This tiebreaker field should contain a unique value for each document.
+If you don't include a tiebreaker field, your paged results could miss or duplicate hits.
+
+NOTE: Search after requests have optimizations that make them faster when the sort
+order is `_shard_doc` and total hits are not tracked. If you want to iterate over all documents regardless of the
+order, this is the most efficient option.
 
 [source,console]
 ----
@@ -90,18 +96,47 @@ GET /_search
 	    "keep_alive": "1m"
   },
   "sort": [ <2>
-    {"@timestamp": "asc"},
-    {"tie_breaker_id": "asc"}
+    {"@timestamp": "asc"}
   ]
 }
 ----
 // TEST[catch:missing]
 
 <1> PIT ID for the search.
-<2> Sorts hits for the search.
+<2> Sorts hits for the search with an implicit tiebreak on `_shard_doc` ascending.
 
 The search response includes an array of `sort` values for each hit. If you used
-a PIT, the response's `pit_id` parameter contains an updated PIT ID.
+a PIT, a tiebreaker is included as the last `sort` values for each hit.
+This tiebreaker called `_shard_doc` is added automically on every search requests that use a PIT.
+The `_shard_doc` value is the combination of the shard index within the PIT and the Lucene's internal doc ID,
+it is unique per document and constant within a PIT.
+You can also add the tiebreaker explicitly in the search request to customize the order:
+
+[source,console]
+----
+GET /_search
+{
+  "size": 10000,
+  "query": {
+    "match" : {
+      "user.id" : "elkbee"
+    }
+  },
+  "pit": {
+	    "id":  "46ToAwMDaWR5BXV1aWQyKwZub2RlXzMAAAAAAAAAACoBYwADaWR4BXV1aWQxAgZub2RlXzEAAAAAAAAAAAEBYQADaWR5BXV1aWQyKgZub2RlXzIAAAAAAAAAAAwBYgACBXV1aWQyAAAFdXVpZDEAAQltYXRjaF9hbGw_gAAAAA==", <1>
+	    "keep_alive": "1m"
+  },
+  "sort": [ <2>
+    {"@timestamp": "asc"},
+    {"_shard_doc": "desc"}
+  ]
+}
+----
+// TEST[catch:missing]
+
+<1> PIT ID for the search.
+<2> Sorts hits for the search with an explicit tiebreak on `_shard_doc` descending.
+
 
 [source,console-result]
 ----
@@ -122,7 +157,7 @@ a PIT, the response's `pit_id` parameter contains an updated PIT ID.
         "_source" : ...,
         "sort" : [                                <2>
           4098435132000,
-          "FaslK3QBySSL_rrj9zM5"
+          4294967298                              <3>
         ]
       }
     ]
@@ -133,9 +168,10 @@ a PIT, the response's `pit_id` parameter contains an updated PIT ID.
 
 <1> Updated `id` for the point in time.
 <2> Sort values for the last returned hit.
+<3> The tiebreaker value, unique per document within the `pit_id`.
 
 To get the next page of results, rerun the previous search using the last hit's
-sort values as the `search_after` argument. If using a PIT, use the latest PIT
+sort values (including the tiebreaker) as the `search_after` argument. If using a PIT, use the latest PIT
 ID in the `pit.id` parameter. The search's `query` and `sort` arguments must
 remain unchanged. If provided, the `from` argument must be `0` (default) or `-1`.
 
@@ -154,19 +190,20 @@ GET /_search
 	    "keep_alive": "1m"
   },
   "sort": [
-    {"@timestamp": "asc"},
-    {"tie_breaker_id": "asc"}
+    {"@timestamp": "asc"}
   ],
   "search_after": [                                <2>
     4098435132000,
-    "FaslK3QBySSL_rrj9zM5"
-  ]
+    4294967298
+  ],
+  "track_total_hits": false                        <3>
 }
 ----
 // TEST[catch:missing]
 
 <1> PIT ID returned by the previous search.
 <2> Sort values from the previous search's last hit.
+<3> Disable the tracking of total hits to speed up pagination.
 
 You can repeat this process to get additional pages of results. If using a PIT,
 you can extend the PIT's retention period using the

server/src/main/java/org/elasticsearch/action/search/SearchRequest.java

@@ -19,6 +19,8 @@ import org.elasticsearch.common.io.stream.StreamInput;
 import org.elasticsearch.common.io.stream.StreamOutput;
 import org.elasticsearch.common.unit.TimeValue;
 import org.elasticsearch.common.xcontent.ToXContent;
+import org.elasticsearch.index.query.QueryRewriteContext;
+import org.elasticsearch.index.query.Rewriteable;
 import org.elasticsearch.search.Scroll;
 import org.elasticsearch.search.builder.PointInTimeBuilder;
 import org.elasticsearch.search.builder.SearchSourceBuilder;
@@ -26,11 +28,14 @@ import org.elasticsearch.search.internal.SearchContext;
 import org.elasticsearch.search.sort.FieldSortBuilder;
 import org.elasticsearch.search.sort.SortBuilder;
 import org.elasticsearch.search.sort.ShardDocSortField;
+import org.elasticsearch.search.sort.SortBuilders;
 import org.elasticsearch.tasks.TaskId;
 
 import java.io.IOException;
+import java.util.ArrayList;
 import java.util.Arrays;
 import java.util.Collections;
+import java.util.List;
 import java.util.Map;
 import java.util.Objects;
 
@@ -48,7 +53,7 @@ import static org.elasticsearch.action.ValidateActions.addValidationError;
  * @see org.elasticsearch.client.Client#search(SearchRequest)
  * @see SearchResponse
  */
-public class SearchRequest extends ActionRequest implements IndicesRequest.Replaceable {
+public class SearchRequest extends ActionRequest implements IndicesRequest.Replaceable, Rewriteable<SearchRequest> {
 
     public static final ToXContent.Params FORMAT_PARAMS = new ToXContent.MapParams(Collections.singletonMap("pretty", "false"));
 
@@ -641,6 +646,35 @@ public class SearchRequest extends ActionRequest implements IndicesRequest.Repla
         return resolveTrackTotalHitsUpTo(scroll, source);
     }
 
+    @Override
+    public SearchRequest rewrite(QueryRewriteContext ctx) throws IOException {
+        if (source == null) {
+            return this;
+        }
+
+        SearchSourceBuilder source = this.source.rewrite(ctx);
+        boolean hasChanged = source != this.source;
+
+        // add a sort tiebreaker for PIT search requests if not explicitly set
+        Object[] searchAfter = source.searchAfter();
+        if (source.pointInTimeBuilder() != null
+                && source.sorts() != null
+                && source.sorts().isEmpty() == false
+                // skip the tiebreaker if it is not provided in the search after values
+                && (searchAfter == null || searchAfter.length == source.sorts().size()+1)) {
+            SortBuilder<?> lastSort = source.sorts().get(source.sorts().size() - 1);
+            if (lastSort instanceof FieldSortBuilder == false
+                    || FieldSortBuilder.SHARD_DOC_FIELD_NAME.equals(((FieldSortBuilder) lastSort).getFieldName()) == false) {
+                List<SortBuilder<?>> newSorts = new ArrayList<>(source.sorts());
+                newSorts.add(SortBuilders.pitTiebreaker().unmappedType("long"));
+                source = source.shallowCopy().sort(newSorts);
+                hasChanged = true;
+            }
+        }
+
+        return hasChanged ? new SearchRequest(this).source(source) : this;
+    }
+
     public static int resolveTrackTotalHitsUpTo(Scroll scroll, SearchSourceBuilder source) {
         if (scroll != null) {
             // no matter what the value of track_total_hits is

server/src/main/java/org/elasticsearch/action/search/TransportSearchAction.java

@@ -259,42 +259,39 @@ public class TransportSearchAction extends HandledTransportAction<SearchRequest,
         }, listener);
     }
 
-    private void executeRequest(Task task, SearchRequest searchRequest,
-                                SearchAsyncActionProvider searchAsyncActionProvider, ActionListener<SearchResponse> listener) {
+    private void executeRequest(Task task,
+                                SearchRequest original,
+                                SearchAsyncActionProvider searchAsyncActionProvider,
+                                ActionListener<SearchResponse> listener) {
         final long relativeStartNanos = System.nanoTime();
         final SearchTimeProvider timeProvider =
-            new SearchTimeProvider(searchRequest.getOrCreateAbsoluteStartMillis(), relativeStartNanos, System::nanoTime);
-        ActionListener<SearchSourceBuilder> rewriteListener = ActionListener.wrap(source -> {
-            if (source != searchRequest.source()) {
-                // only set it if it changed - we don't allow null values to be set but it might be already null. this way we catch
-                // situations when source is rewritten to null due to a bug
-                searchRequest.source(source);
-            }
+            new SearchTimeProvider(original.getOrCreateAbsoluteStartMillis(), relativeStartNanos, System::nanoTime);
+        ActionListener<SearchRequest> rewriteListener = ActionListener.wrap(rewritten -> {
             final SearchContextId searchContext;
             final Map<String, OriginalIndices> remoteClusterIndices;
-            if (searchRequest.pointInTimeBuilder() != null) {
-                searchContext = searchRequest.pointInTimeBuilder().getSearchContextId(namedWriteableRegistry);
-                remoteClusterIndices = getIndicesFromSearchContexts(searchContext, searchRequest.indicesOptions());
+            if (rewritten.pointInTimeBuilder() != null) {
+                searchContext = rewritten.pointInTimeBuilder().getSearchContextId(namedWriteableRegistry);
+                remoteClusterIndices = getIndicesFromSearchContexts(searchContext, rewritten.indicesOptions());
             } else {
                 searchContext = null;
-                remoteClusterIndices = remoteClusterService.groupIndices(searchRequest.indicesOptions(), searchRequest.indices());
+                remoteClusterIndices = remoteClusterService.groupIndices(rewritten.indicesOptions(), rewritten.indices());
             }
             OriginalIndices localIndices = remoteClusterIndices.remove(RemoteClusterAware.LOCAL_CLUSTER_GROUP_KEY);
             final ClusterState clusterState = clusterService.state();
             if (remoteClusterIndices.isEmpty()) {
                 executeLocalSearch(
-                    task, timeProvider, searchRequest, localIndices, clusterState, listener, searchContext, searchAsyncActionProvider);
+                    task, timeProvider, rewritten, localIndices, clusterState, listener, searchContext, searchAsyncActionProvider);
             } else {
-                if (shouldMinimizeRoundtrips(searchRequest)) {
+                if (shouldMinimizeRoundtrips(rewritten)) {
                     final TaskId parentTaskId = task.taskInfo(clusterService.localNode().getId(), false).getTaskId();
-                    ccsRemoteReduce(parentTaskId, searchRequest, localIndices, remoteClusterIndices, timeProvider,
-                        searchService.aggReduceContextBuilder(searchRequest),
+                    ccsRemoteReduce(parentTaskId, rewritten, localIndices, remoteClusterIndices, timeProvider,
+                        searchService.aggReduceContextBuilder(rewritten),
                         remoteClusterService, threadPool, listener,
                         (r, l) -> executeLocalSearch(
                             task, timeProvider, r, localIndices, clusterState, l, searchContext, searchAsyncActionProvider));
                 } else {
                     AtomicInteger skippedClusters = new AtomicInteger(0);
-                    collectSearchShards(searchRequest.indicesOptions(), searchRequest.preference(), searchRequest.routing(),
+                    collectSearchShards(rewritten.indicesOptions(), rewritten.preference(), rewritten.routing(),
                         skippedClusters, remoteClusterIndices, remoteClusterService, threadPool,
                         ActionListener.wrap(
                             searchShardsResponses -> {
@@ -305,7 +302,7 @@ public class TransportSearchAction extends HandledTransportAction<SearchRequest,
                                 if (searchContext != null) {
                                     remoteAliasFilters = searchContext.aliasFilter();
                                     remoteShardIterators = getRemoteShardsIteratorFromPointInTime(searchShardsResponses,
-                                        searchContext, searchRequest.pointInTimeBuilder().getKeepAlive(), remoteClusterIndices);
+                                        searchContext, rewritten.pointInTimeBuilder().getKeepAlive(), remoteClusterIndices);
                                 } else {
                                     remoteAliasFilters = getRemoteAliasFilters(searchShardsResponses);
                                     remoteShardIterators = getRemoteShardsIterator(searchShardsResponses, remoteClusterIndices,
@@ -314,7 +311,7 @@ public class TransportSearchAction extends HandledTransportAction<SearchRequest,
                                 int localClusters = localIndices == null ? 0 : 1;
                                 int totalClusters = remoteClusterIndices.size() + localClusters;
                                 int successfulClusters = searchShardsResponses.size() + localClusters;
-                                executeSearch((SearchTask) task, timeProvider, searchRequest, localIndices, remoteShardIterators,
+                                executeSearch((SearchTask) task, timeProvider, rewritten, localIndices, remoteShardIterators,
                                     clusterNodeLookup, clusterState, remoteAliasFilters, listener,
                                     new SearchResponse.Clusters(totalClusters, successfulClusters, skippedClusters.get()),
                                     searchContext, searchAsyncActionProvider);
@@ -323,12 +320,8 @@ public class TransportSearchAction extends HandledTransportAction<SearchRequest,
                 }
             }
         }, listener::onFailure);
-        if (searchRequest.source() == null) {
-            rewriteListener.onResponse(searchRequest.source());
-        } else {
-            Rewriteable.rewriteAndFetch(searchRequest.source(), searchService.getRewriteContext(timeProvider::getAbsoluteStartMillis),
-                rewriteListener);
-        }
+        Rewriteable.rewriteAndFetch(original, searchService.getRewriteContext(timeProvider::getAbsoluteStartMillis),
+            rewriteListener);
     }
 
     static boolean shouldMinimizeRoundtrips(SearchRequest searchRequest) {

server/src/main/java/org/elasticsearch/search/builder/SearchSourceBuilder.java

@@ -531,7 +531,15 @@ public final class SearchSourceBuilder implements Writeable, ToXContentObject, R
     }
 
     /**
-     * Gets the bytes representing the sort builders for this request.
+     * Sets the sort builders for this request.
+     */
+    public SearchSourceBuilder sort(List<SortBuilder<?>> sorts) {
+        this.sorts = sorts;
+        return this;
+    }
+
+    /**
+     * Gets the sort builders for this request.
      */
     public List<SortBuilder<?>> sorts() {
         return sorts;

x-pack/plugin/core/src/internalClusterTest/java/org/elasticsearch/xpack/core/search/PointInTimeIT.java

@@ -396,8 +396,17 @@ public class PointInTimeIT extends ESIntegTestCase {
         try {
             for (int size = 1; size <= numIndex; size++) {
                 SortOrder order = randomBoolean() ? SortOrder.ASC : SortOrder.DESC;
+
                 assertPagination(new PointInTimeBuilder(pit), expectedNumDocs, size,
                     SortBuilders.pitTiebreaker().order(order));
+
+                assertPagination(new PointInTimeBuilder(pit), expectedNumDocs, size,
+                    SortBuilders.scoreSort());
+                assertPagination(new PointInTimeBuilder(pit), expectedNumDocs, size,
+                    SortBuilders.scoreSort(), SortBuilders.pitTiebreaker().order(order));
+
+                assertPagination(new PointInTimeBuilder(pit), expectedNumDocs, size,
+                    SortBuilders.fieldSort("value"));
                 assertPagination(new PointInTimeBuilder(pit), expectedNumDocs, size,
                     SortBuilders.fieldSort("value"), SortBuilders.pitTiebreaker().order(order));
             }
@@ -406,18 +415,21 @@ public class PointInTimeIT extends ESIntegTestCase {
         }
     }
 
-    private void assertPagination(PointInTimeBuilder pit, int expectedNumDocs, int size, SortBuilder<?>... sort) throws Exception {
+    private void assertPagination(PointInTimeBuilder pit, int expectedNumDocs, int size, SortBuilder<?>... sorts) throws Exception {
         Set<String> seen = new HashSet<>();
         SearchRequestBuilder builder = client().prepareSearch()
             .setSize(size)
             .setPointInTime(pit);
+        for (SortBuilder<?> sort : sorts) {
+            builder.addSort(sort);
+        }
+        final SearchRequest searchRequest = builder.request().rewrite(null);
 
-        final int[] reverseMuls = new int[sort.length];
-        for (int i = 0; i < sort.length; i++) {
-            builder.addSort(sort[i]);
-            reverseMuls[i] = sort[i].order() == SortOrder.ASC ? 1 : -1;
+        final List<SortBuilder<?>> expectedSorts = searchRequest.source().sorts();
+        final int[] reverseMuls = new int[expectedSorts.size()];
+        for (int i = 0; i < expectedSorts.size(); i++) {
+            reverseMuls[i] = expectedSorts.get(i).order() == SortOrder.ASC ? 1 : -1;
         }
-        final SearchRequest searchRequest = builder.request();
         SearchResponse response = client().search(searchRequest).get();
         Object[] lastSortValues = null;
         while (response.getHits().getHits().length > 0) {
@@ -426,7 +438,7 @@ public class PointInTimeIT extends ESIntegTestCase {
                 assertTrue(seen.add(hit.getIndex() + hit.getId()));
 
                 if (lastHitSortValues != null) {
-                    for (int i = 0; i < sort.length; i++) {
+                    for (int i = 0; i < expectedSorts.size(); i++) {
                         Comparable value = (Comparable) hit.getRawSortValues()[i];
                         int cmp = value.compareTo(lastHitSortValues[i]) * reverseMuls[i];
                         if (cmp != 0) {
@@ -440,7 +452,7 @@ public class PointInTimeIT extends ESIntegTestCase {
             int len = response.getHits().getHits().length;
             SearchHit last = response.getHits().getHits()[len - 1];
             if (lastSortValues != null) {
-                for (int i = 0; i < sort.length; i++) {
+                for (int i = 0; i < expectedSorts.size(); i++) {
                     Comparable value = (Comparable) last.getSortValues()[i];
                     int cmp = value.compareTo(lastSortValues[i]) * reverseMuls[i];
                     if (cmp != 0) {
@@ -449,7 +461,7 @@ public class PointInTimeIT extends ESIntegTestCase {
                     }
                 }
             }
-            assertThat(last.getSortValues().length, equalTo(sort.length));
+            assertThat(last.getSortValues().length, equalTo(expectedSorts.size()));
             lastSortValues = last.getSortValues();
             searchRequest.source().searchAfter(last.getSortValues());
             response = client().search(searchRequest).get();

x-pack/plugin/src/test/resources/rest-api-spec/test/data_stream/10_data_stream_resolvability.yml

@@ -675,7 +675,8 @@
   - length: {hits.hits: 1 }
   - match: {hits.hits.0._index: "/\\.ds-simple-data-stream1-(\\d{4}\\.\\d{2}\\.\\d{2}-)?000001/" }
   - match: {hits.hits.0._id: "123" }
-  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort: [22, 123] }
+  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort.0: 22}
+  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort.1: 123}
 
   - do:
       search:
@@ -693,7 +694,8 @@
   - length: {hits.hits: 1 }
   - match: {hits.hits.0._index: "/\\.ds-simple-data-stream1-(\\d{4}\\.\\d{2}\\.\\d{2}-)?000001/" }
   - match: {hits.hits.0._id: "5" }
-  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort: [18, 5] }
+  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort.0: 18}
+  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort.1: 5}
 
   - do:
       search:
@@ -712,7 +714,8 @@
   - length: {hits.hits: 1 }
   - match: {hits.hits.0._index: "/\\.ds-simple-data-stream1-(\\d{4}\\.\\d{2}\\.\\d{2}-)?000001/" }
   - match: {hits.hits.0._id: "1" }
-  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort: [18, 1] }
+  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort.0: 18}
+  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort.1: 1}
 
   - do:
       search:

x-pack/plugin/src/test/resources/rest-api-spec/test/search/point_in_time.yml

@@ -61,7 +61,8 @@ setup:
   - length: {hits.hits: 1 }
   - match: {hits.hits.0._index: test }
   - match: {hits.hits.0._id: "172" }
-  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort: [24, 172] }
+  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort.0: 24}
+  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort.1: 172}
 
   - do:
       index:
@@ -89,7 +90,8 @@ setup:
   - length: {hits.hits: 1 }
   - match: {hits.hits.0._index: test }
   - match: {hits.hits.0._id: "42" }
-  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort: [18, 42] }
+  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort.0: 18}
+  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort.1: 42}
 
   - do:
       search:
@@ -107,7 +109,8 @@ setup:
   - length: {hits.hits: 1 }
   - match: {hits.hits.0._index: test }
   - match: {hits.hits.0._id: "1" }
-  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort: [18, 1] }
+  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort.0: 18}
+  - match: {hits.hits.0.sort.1: 1}
 
   - do:
       search: